Why I Used Drupal
There is so much war going on between the fanatics of the different open-source content management systems. I’d say it’s between Wordpress, Joomla and Drupal. They each have their pros and cons, strengths and weaknesses, and I’ve used all of them. I have seen a ton of designers make their online portfolios based on a Wordpress installation, and it’s always bothered me. I had a lot of debate with myself which one to use for my portfolio site, or if I should even bother using one at all, and in the end, I chose Drupal. Here’s why:
Customizability, Scalability, and Flexibility
Absolutely every stitch of information on this website, from header to footer, is somehow contained and managed by Drupal. I can easily move content around to different locations on the page, or different pages altogether. I can just as easily edit or remove that information. The whole web site was designed with complete flexibility – I can change to whatever I would need it to do in the future easily and efficiently. A Drupal site can grow as your business grows.
The Shoe Fit
Drupal certainly is complex and confusing, there’s no doubt about that. I can definitely agree with everybody that getting a customized Wordpress installation up and running is way easier than Drupal. However, Drupal can be made to do whatever you want. It’s confusing because it’s customizable. It can be made to fit whatever purpose you want it to fill.
I’m a Control Freak
It’s probably the same reason I love PCs. I built many of my own computers and love the ability to decide how my computer runs at every level. I don’t like Mac for the simple reason that it puts handcuffs on me when I turn it on. Some people think it makes the experience easier, I think it takes away the control I love.
A Drupal site is very much the same way. There are probably thousands of very different uses of a content management system and there’s no such thing as a one-size-fits-all. Drupal, however, can be molded and shaped via modules and customized programming. This can make it the perfect tool for just about any web project, assuming you have the know-how to set it up.
Speed Test
I only started with Drupal this year and have since set up a handful of sites for pro bono clients as a way to learn more about the system. I have been converted! I still love Wordpress, and definitely recommend it and use it, but it has it’s very specific place. With the projects I’ve gotten involved in, I felt my skills were sharpened enough that I knew what I was doing and wanted to see how fast I could set up a Drupal site. I can’t tell you how long it actually took, as I am employed full time and had a brand new baby boy in the middle (congratulations to me!) but in the end, I think that it does take a little longer than some of the other options out there. I do think that the extra time makes for a much better result, as you have a completed website with complete scalability and flexibility, and all the other things I mentioned previously.
I’m certainly a Drupal convert, and I urge all other fellow designers out there who are overwhelmed by the complexity of Drupal to sit back with a few cold beers and plow in! It’s a tough road, but there’s a pot of gold at the end.

Comments
Just a small note - I do not want this to be a This vs. That post. This article was about pushing designers to try Drupal in place of something ill-suited for the task at hand.
Tevi - great article. It's great to hear your take on things. I have been waiting for this open source war to finally deliver a victor, but my guess is that the future includes even more options. Your article is persuasive - I simply do not have the time to become fully fluent in Drupal & Joomla & WordPress & Blogger & etc, before one of them hopefully becomes the defacto standard. Not while web standards and HTML5 are still in flux. My fear is that the future holds NO defacto standard, and we (web designers) will be continually presented with even more frameworks, guidelines, standards, devices, screen sizes, and color palettes. It is a continually moving target...the ability to adjust overrides everything else. Great article.
hello
the graphic of this site is amazing beautiful. I wonder if it can be change to fit rtl site.
I agree that drupal has tough road;
especially in rtl (Hebrew, Arabic site) but has it's worth.
Thanks guys!
@David - the future is a moving target; or, rather not even a target. Technology is always changing and we have to use the best tools we have now, and something which has foreseeable flexibility and adaptability.
@ביטוח רכב - I've not yet experimented with RTL (in Drupal, or even in straight HTML). Officially, this theme can support it, but it's untested. Have you used any other CMSs specifically for RTL languages?
No mention of Plone? I've used it for Loyola Computer Science at http://www.cs.luc.edu . Complicated but very powerful. Once committed to Plone, I've resisted changing, but I have wondered if Drupal might be easier but still powerful enough.
I think that a CMS should be as simpler as possible. So, I chose CMS made simple, that still has many flaws, but gives you total control on what you do (without bothering with taxonomy and other absurd abstract layers of knowledge).
I run an installation of Drupal: how hard is to add a "target = "_blank" " in menu links? Many will say that it doesn't follow web standards and so on, but when it comes to control, I would like to have full flexibility on what I do.
target=_blank can be added to links without much trouble. Depends on where you're trying to accomplish this, though. I would not ever do it for menu links, though! People never expect to leave your site when they click a menu item.
obviously, I needed to add it only in a few entries on menu, that I wanted to redirect to external sites. And I had to add the "externallinks" module, then further tweak it to behave exactly as I want. Pretty rusty I think, but for Drupal developers the only importance is being compliant. No matter about usability.
Now, Now Peter! Let's see what Drupal 7 has to offer! Usability is one of the primary concerns with the new D7, and it should be out soon! Let's keep our fingers crossed.
Really looking forward to new release! Hope to find great improvements in usability, theming and authoring
I love working with Joomla the easiest most robust CMS out The admin panel is a breeze article posting is super easy and with all the modules like CB and Virtumart there is very little limit to what you can do in Joomla
Post new comment